Where to Stay in St. Augustine: Best Areas & Hotels

St. Augustine, originally San Agustín de la Florida, is often called “The Ancient City” and is packed with history and charm. Located on the northeastern coast of Florida, it was founded in 1565 by Spanish explorers, making it the oldest continuously occupied European-established settlement in the continental United States. With its cobblestone streets, stunning Spanish architecture, and historic landmarks, St. Augustine feels like stepping back in time. If you’re looking for the best areas to stay in St. Augustine, you’ve come to the right place.

---

St. Augustine’s rich history permeates every corner of the city. Its most famous attraction is the Castillo de San Marcos, a 17th-century stone fortress offering panoramic views of the bay. Flagler College, once a grand hotel founded by Henry Flagler, showcases stunning Spanish Renaissance architecture. The city’s tourist industry is robust, attracting millions annually. This means you’ll find all types of accommodations, from luxury hotels to quaint bed-and-breakfasts and inns.

Explore other St. Augustine attractions like the Lighthouse & Maritime Museum, which offers breathtaking views from its top. The Lightner Museum, housed in the former Alcazar Hotel, boasts an impressive collection of artifacts and artworks. The Fountain of Youth Archaeological Park claims to be the site where Ponce de León searched for the mythical waters. For family fun, check out Ripley’s Believe It or Not! Museum, located in an old manor.

St. Augustine has a relaxed atmosphere that’s both tourist-friendly and welcoming. The city is known for its lively local arts scene and frequent festivals that bring a special energy to its historic districts. You’ll find charming local shops and restaurants offering fresh seafood along Avenida Menendez, right by the waterfront.

Continue reading this guide to discover more about this fascinating city’s best areas to stay and find your ideal accommodation in St. Augustine.

---

Accommodation Options in St. Augustine, FL

---

---

What’s the Best Area to Stay in St. Augustine, FL?

The best area to stay in St. Augustine is the Spanish Quarter. Also known as the Colonial Quarter, it features beautifully restored 18th-century buildings, quaint streets, and a charming atmosphere. Visitors can enjoy unique shops, traditional restaurants, and rich historical landmarks, all within walking distance. Staying here offers a chance to be immersed in early colonial life while enjoying the conveniences and comforts of modern amenities, making it an excellent choice.

Find available accommodation in the Spanish Quarter.

Best Hotels in the Spanish Quarter, Saint Augustine

• Best 4-star hotel: The Collector Inn (Adults Only) – Saint Augustine
• Best 3-star hotel: Best Western Historic Bayfront
• Best budget hotel: Economy Inn Historic District
• Best B&B: Carriage Way Inn Bed & Breakfast Adults Only

---

The Best Areas to Stay in Saint Augustine for Sightseeing

While the Spanish Quarter is the best location for tourists in St Augustine, this attraction-packed area is not the only option. Other areas can be just as fun and convenient, depending on your interests. These are some recommended areas to stay in Saint Augustine:

• The Spanish Quarter is the historic heart of St. Augustine, offering a glimpse into the city’s colonial past. This area is home to a collection of restored homes and museums that showcase life during the 18th century under Spanish rule.
• Saint Augustine Beach is a popular destination for those looking to enjoy the sun, surf, and sand. This area features miles of pristine coastline and opportunities for water sports like surfing, paddleboarding, and fishing.
• Vilano Beach is a charming seaside community known for its retro Florida vibe and serene beachfront. The area boasts unique Art Deco architecture and offers stunning views of both the Atlantic Ocean and Intracoastal Waterway.
• Anastasia Island features natural beauty and convenient access to downtown St. Augustine. The island is home to Anastasia State Park, which offers protected dunes, maritime hammocks, tidal salt marshes, and white sandy beaches.
• Lincolnville is one of St. Augustine’s oldest neighborhoods. Emancipated slaves founded it after the Civil War. This area showcases beautiful Victorian homes along picturesque streets lined with moss-draped oaks.

---

The Best Areas to Stay in St Augustine: Top Areas & Hotels

The Spanish Quarter is located in the heart of historic St. Augustine and offers visitors a glimpse into its rich colonial past.

Why is this the best area to stay in St. Augutstine:
• Rich historic atmosphere
• Scenic views of Matanzas Bay
• Cobblestone streets
• Proximity to Castillo de San Marcos
• Vibrant nightlife
• Unique local shops
• Flagler College
• Seasonal events and festivals
• Variety of dining options
• Historic landmarks

St. Augustine’s Colonial Quarter is situated in the central area of St. Augustine, Florida, offering a significant glimpse into the early Spanish colonial period in American history. Established in 1565 by Spanish admiral Pedro Menéndez de Avilés, this area is known for its meticulously preserved and reconstructed buildings, which provide an immersive experience into 16th and 17th-century colonial life.

The Colonial Quarter features notable attractions such as the Castillo de San Marcos, a 17th-century stone fortress constructed to defend Spain’s interests in the New World. This national monument provides valuable insights into the military architecture and defense mechanisms of its time. The Colonial Oak Music Park is an open-air venue that frequently hosts live music performances and cultural events.

For those interested in religious history, the Cathedral Basilica of St. Augustine, constructed in the late 18th century, is a testament to the city’s enduring Spanish Catholic heritage. Another significant landmark is the Governor’s House Cultural Center and Museum, a pivotal administrative center since its construction during Florida’s second Spanish period (1784-1821).

The area maintains a lively atmosphere throughout the day, with a selection of restaurants and shops lining its narrow streets. Nightlife in St. Augustine’s Colonial Quarter includes several taverns and bars to enjoy local cuisine and drinks. Many venues offer live music or storytelling sessions emphasizing local folklore and history.

Transportation within St. Augustine is facilitated by several trolley services offering hop-on-hop-off options, making it convenient to explore not only the Colonial Quarter but other parts of the city. Additionally, bike rentals are available for those who prefer a more active exploration mode.

Accommodation options range from boutique hotels in historical buildings to more contemporary inns and bed-and-breakfast establishments.

Best Hotels in the Spanish Quarter, St. Augustine

---

Saint Augustine Beach is a popular destination for those looking to soak up the sun and enjoy pristine sandy shores.

Why is this the best area to stay in St. Augutstine:
• Beautiful sandy beaches
• Historic sites and landmarks
• Family-friendly environment
• Variety of restaurants and cafes
• St. Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum nearby

St. Augustine Beach, part of the historic city of St. Augustine, is located on Anastasia Island along the Atlantic coast. This area offers a compelling blend of natural beauty and rich history.

The beach itself stretches for miles with soft white sands and clear waters, ideal for sunbathing, swimming, and hiking along the shoreline. Its location provides spectacular sunrise views and opportunities for various water sports such as sea kayaking, paddleboarding, and surfing. The St. Johns County Ocean Pier is a notable landmark offering amenities like a picnic pavilion, volleyball courts, and a playground.

In addition to its natural attractions, historical sites like the Anastasia State Park offer insights into the area’s diverse ecosystem and its long history. Local attractions include the St. Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum, where visitors can climb 219 steps to enjoy panoramic views of the region. The nearby Alligator Farm Zoological Park delights families with its various reptile exhibits and zip-lining adventures over enclosures.

Nightlife in St. Augustine Beach varies from laid-back beach bars offering live music to cozy seafood restaurants with ocean views.

Several public transport options, including buses that connect key locations in Anastasia Island with downtown St. Augustine, facilitate transportation around St. Augustine Beach. Parking is generally available at main tourist points and beach access areas.

Accommodation in St. Augustine Beach ranges from luxury oceanfront resorts to more affordable motels and vacation rentals.

Best Hotels on St. Augustine Beach

---

Vilano Beach boasts a unique blend of natural beauty and modern amenities. It’s known for its stunning sunrises, less crowded beaches, and excellent shelling opportunities.

Why is this the best area to stay in St. Augutstine:
• Peaceful and quiet environment
• Beautiful and wide sandy beaches
• Proximity to historic downtown St. Augustine
• Stunning sunrise views over the ocean

Vilano Beach is a serene coastal community located just north of St. Augustine’s historic downtown area. It is bordered by the Atlantic Ocean to the east and the Tolomato River to the west, offering a peaceful retreat from the bustling city center. Vilano Beach’s unique characteristics lie in its natural beauty and tranquil surroundings.

Vilano Beach’s historical significance dates back to the early 20th century when it became a popular destination for tourists arriving by steamship. During the Roaring Twenties, Vilano Beach was known for its dance club, gambling casino, and amusement park. Although these attractions no longer exist, their legacy provides an interesting historical backdrop for this beachside area.

Among the key attractions in Vilano Beach is the Vilano Beach Nature Boardwalk. This boardwalk stretches along the coast and offers stunning ocean views, making it an ideal spot for walking and photography. The Vilano Beach Pier is another notable site; it extends into the Tolomato River and is perfect for fishing or enjoying magnificent sunsets.

Vilano Beach is easily accessible from St. Augustine via the Francis and Mary Usina Bridge, also known as the Vilano Bridge. This bridge connects to A1A, allowing easy travel by car. Public transportation options include bus routes that connect Vilano Beach with other parts of St. Johns County.

Best Hotels on Vilano Beach

---

Anastasia Island is a wonderful place to stay for nature enthusiasts and history buffs. The island features Anastasia State Park, which offers activities such as bird-watching, hiking, and camping.

Why is this the best area to stay in St. Augutstine:
• Stunning beaches
• Quaint local shops
• Proximity to historic downtown
• Anastasia State Park
• St. Augustine Amphitheatre
• Scenic views

Anastasia offers a unique perspective on coastal living adjacent to one of the United States’ oldest cities. This area is located east of downtown St. Augustine, separated by the Matanzas River, which adds a natural barrier and scenic views.

Historically, Anastasia Island has played a significant role in the development and protection of St. Augustine since its founding in 1565. Over the centuries, the island witnessed various historical events but maintained its natural beauty and significance.

Among the notable attractions is Anastasia State Park, a nature lover’s paradise with unspoiled beaches, tidal salt marshes, and maritime hammocks. This park spans over 1,600 acres and offers recreational activities such as kayaking, fishing, and hiking. Close by is the St. Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum, where visitors can climb 219 steps to enjoy panoramic views of the coastline.

For those interested in maritime history or coastal ecosystems, the surrounding waters of Anastasia Island provide opportunities for exploration and education.

Regarding transport options, Anastasia Island is accessible via the Bridge of Lions, connecting it directly to downtown St. Augustine. This ensures that travelers can conveniently visit both urban and natural attractions during their stay. Local transit options include buses that traverse key points on the island.

Accommodations on Anastasia Island include a range of choices, from seaside resorts to charming bed-and-breakfasts.

Best Hotels on Anastasia Island

---

Lincolnville is a historic district that played a significant role in St. Augustine’s civil rights movement.

Lincolnville, located in the southwestern part of St. Augustine, offers a distinctive and enriching stay for anyone interested in American history and culture. Founded by freedmen after the Civil War in 1866, Lincolnville has played a critical role in the Civil Rights Movement and reflects a rich African American heritage.

Positioned near St. Augustine’s downtown area, Lincolnville provides convenient access to the city’s main attractions. Walking through Lincolnville, you’ll encounter historic homes dating back to the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Homes such as the Dumas House, built in 1904, showcase Victorian architectural styles that have been restored over time.

Key landmarks include the Lincolnville Museum and Cultural Center, situated in the former Excelsior School building. The museum features exhibits detailing African American history from post-Civil War to modern Civil Rights struggles. Another notable location is Dr. Robert B. Hayling Freedom Park, named after a local dentist who was a prominent Civil Rights leader in St. Augustine.

Although primarily residential, Lincolnville is within walking distance of St. George Street. Its eclectic mix of shops, dining options, and live music venues offer everything from Southern cuisine to contemporary dishes.

Transportation options are convenient, with several bus routes running through or near Lincolnville, linking it effectively with other parts of St. Augustine. The area is also pedestrian-friendly due to its narrow streets originally designed for horse-drawn carriages.

Best Hotels in Lincolnville, St. Augustine

---

Staying in Saint Augustine: A Personal Take

Staying in the colonial area is highly recommended when finding good accommodation in Saint Augustine, FL. This part of the city has much to offer regarding history and culture. During my recent visit, I stayed at the three-star Best Western Historic Bayfront. This hotel is located right on Avenida Menendez, offering a prime spot to explore the city’s historic downtown. The place offers views of Matanzas Bay and is conveniently close to attractions like Castillo de San Marcos and St. George Street. The walkability factor here is fantastic; you don’t really need a car to get around this area.

If you’re more inclined to enjoy the beach, then Vilano Beach or St. Augustine Beach could be better options. These areas are slightly more relaxed compared to the bustling downtown. However, remember that staying at places like Best Western Historic Bayfront provides a unique blend of convenience and charm that’s hard to beat if you want a deeper sense of Saint Augustine’s colonial history. From architecture to street performances and cozy eateries, every corner tells a story, making your stay both convenient and enriching.

---

Where to Stay in St. Augustine: Useful Information

St. Augustine, Florida, is the oldest city in the U.S. and is a wonderful place to visit. Getting there can be done by flying into Jacksonville International Airport (JAX), about an hour’s drive away. Alternatively, Orlando International Airport (MCO) can be used, roughly two hours away by car.

St. Augustine has a compact historic district, making it easy to explore on foot. The city is very walkable, especially around the historic district with its narrow streets and pedestrian-friendly areas. For public transportation, St. Augustine offers a trolley system with lines like Old Town Trolley Tours and Red Train Tours that cover major attractions.

While you’re there, don’t miss out on trying local dishes such as Minorcan clam chowder and datil pepper hot sauce, which are unique to the area.

The climate in St. Augustine is humid and subtropical. Summers are hot, with temperatures averaging around 30°C (86°F). Winters are mild, with temperatures usually hovering around 15°C (59°F). Spring and fall are very pleasant, with temperatures ranging from 20-25°C (68-77°F).

You cannot miss visiting Castillo de San Marcos, a well-preserved 17th-century Spanish stone fortress with incredible water views. Three other attractions worth visiting include the Fountain of Youth Archaeological Park, St. George Street for shopping and dining, and the St. Augustine Alligator Farm Zoological Park.

If you want to stay close to the action, consider staying in the historic district, where you’ll be within walking distance of most attractions and restaurants. Anastasia Island and Vilano Beach are also great areas to consider for lodging, as they have beautiful beach views and easy access back to downtown.

For those traveling on a budget, look for accommodations further inland or consider staying at a bed-and-breakfast that offers complimentary breakfast to save on meals. Make sure to book in advance, as places can fill up quickly, especially during peak tourist seasons.

---